≡ Menu

Analogy of the day

Courtesy of Apple Matters, from their story titled Note to the Recording Industry: The iPod is not Mtv:

The entire debate really comes down to the following truth: the record companies want more money out of the honest folks who are willing to pay for their music. Before iTunes came along everyone who swapped mp3s could be considered a music thief. When the iTunes music store rolled out a few honest swappers jumped at the chance to go legal. The Music industry regards these folks as sheeple and plans to get them to pay not only for their past sins but for all the sins of file swappers everywhere.
Here one is reminded of the case of Count Fulk the Black of Anjou. The Count, history tells us, was a really bad guy responsible for all sorts of disgusting crimes. At some point the Count decided he wanted to get right with the powers that be so he appealed to the local religious leaders for absolution. Not content with a few prayers and a donation the religious leaders of the day sentenced the Count to a triple pilgrimage to Jerusalem…while shackled. So the Count trudged across France, the Alps, Syria and Jordan and back again three times in chains. Finally, to add insult to grievous injury, on the last trip he was tied to a hurdle and dragged through the streets while being unmercifully whipped by two stout fellows. It is hard to say that downloading music from P2P sites is quite as bad as the crimes committed by the Black Count (though the music industry would probably argue otherwise) but the outcome is the same. When offered a legal option those who seem to be willing to make amends and do what is right will be the ones most damaged by the record companies actions.

Brilliant stuff!

Comments on this entry are closed.

  • James Bailey

    The reality is that the RIAA doesn’t care that the iTunes Music Store works and sells. They don’t even want to sell CDs any longer. What they want is absolute control of when and where you listen and to be sure that you pay them each and every time you do so.

    What they want is subscription services. Ultimately, that is what the rhetoric about cutting off Apple’s access to songs and raising prices is about. They want to kill both illegal AND LEGAL downloading of individual songs to force everyone to use subscriptions and keep paying forever.

Next post:

Previous post: